How to Remove Mistakes from Your Background Check
Have you ever wondered whether the information in your background check is actually accurate?
You might be surprised to learn that mistakes happen more often than many people realize. A background report may contain outdated information, records that belong to someone else, or information that should no longer appear. In February 2024, the National Institute of Justice sponsored a study showing that 60% of background checks contained a false-positive (i.e., the person was wrongly flagged for a criminal record) while up to 90% of background checks contained false-negatives (i.e., material omissions from a person’s record). These errors can affect employment, housing, insurance, and other important opportunities.
The good news is that you have rights under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) if inaccurate information appears in a consumer report.
Here's how to start the correction process.
Step 1: Review Your Background Report Carefully
Before disputing anything, take time to review the report line by line.
Look for issues such as:
Records that belong to another person
Incorrect personal information (name, date of birth, address)
Duplicate records
Incorrect case dispositions
Charges reported as convictions when they were dismissed
Records that should have been updated or sealed
Information that appears incomplete or misleading
Even a small error can create confusion during a background check.
Step 2: Identify Who Prepared the Report
Not every background report comes from the same company.
If the report was prepared by a consumer reporting agency (CRA), the FCRA generally gives you the right to dispute inaccurate or incomplete information.
The report should identify the company that prepared it and provide contact information.
Step 3: Gather Supporting Documentation
The stronger your documentation, the easier it is to explain why the information is incorrect.
Helpful documents may include:
Court orders
Case disposition records
Identity documents
Expungement or sealing orders
Correspondence from government agencies
Other official records supporting your position
Keep copies of everything you submit.
Step 4: Submit a Written Dispute
Most consumer reporting agencies allow disputes online, by mail, or by phone.
Your dispute should clearly identify:
The item you believe is inaccurate
Why it is incorrect
What correction you are requesting
Copies (not originals) of supporting documents
Being organized and specific can help the investigation process.
Step 5: The Reporting Agency Investigates
Under the FCRA, consumer reporting agencies generally must investigate qualifying disputes within a specified period, often within 30 days, although certain circumstances may affect that timeframe.
During the investigation, the reporting agency typically contacts the source that provided the information to determine whether it can be verified.
If the information cannot be verified or is determined to be inaccurate, it generally must be corrected or removed.
Step 6: Review the Results
After the investigation is complete, the reporting agency generally must provide the results.
If corrections were made, review the updated report carefully to confirm that the issue was resolved.
If you still believe the information is inaccurate, you may have additional options, including submitting additional documentation or adding a consumer statement to your file in certain circumstances.
What If the Information Is Accurate?
The FCRA helps consumers correct inaccurate information—but it generally does not require accurate information to be removed simply because it is unfavorable.
If the information is accurate, your options may depend on the type of record involved.
For example:
Some criminal records may qualify for expungement or record sealing under state law.
Identity theft may require correcting records with the original source.
Public records maintained by a court may need to be corrected directly with the court.
The appropriate next step depends on your specific circumstances.
💜 Legal Wellness Tip:
Consider these best practices:
Review your reports periodically.
Keep copies of important court documents.
Save records showing disputes and corrections.
Act quickly if you discover an error.
Understand your rights before applying for jobs or housing.
Catching mistakes early may help prevent delays when important opportunities arise.
How Billie Can Help
Billie is designed to help you view, monitor, and better understand your public-record profile so you can identify potential issues before someone else does.
With Billie, you'll be able to:
Review records from multiple public sources
Flag potential inaccuracies
Learn about your rights under the FCRA
Understand possible next steps
Connect with vetted professionals for help
Billie is an educational platform and does not provide legal advice or determine eligibility for employment, housing, credit, or insurance.
Final Thoughts
Mistakes in background reports can happen—but they don't have to define your future.
Knowing your rights under the FCRA and taking prompt action when you identify an error can help ensure that decisions about you are based on accurate information.
Understanding your record is an important part of protecting your legal wellness.
Ready to monitor your public records?
Join the Billie waitlist and be the first to run a FREE Billie Scan to see your background check records: